Columns

MY APOLOGIES FOR THIS SUBJECT MATTER…

At the time of this writing, New York State does NOT yet have an “Apology Law.” An Apology Law would protect healthcare workers, including EMS, from undue charges of negligent actions; this does NOT mean a healthcare worker cannot be charged with negligence, it just means that simply saying “I’m sorry” does not automatically make them liable. This means that EMS providers can be held accountable for malpractice if a patient, or patient’s family can claim that the EMT/Paramedic apologized for their actions.


Bill S4848-2021 was introduced in the New York State Senate to the Civil Practice Law and Rules to exclude expressions of regret from being considered admissions of liability in medical interventions. This does not mean that all health workers are automatically absolved of any wrongdoing, it means that a simple expression cannot be used as proof of guilt and malpractice. Showing your patient empathy would no longer label you as guilty.


“In summary: New York EMS providers currently have no legal shield when they apologize after an adverse event. The proposed S4848 bill would change that, but it has not yet passed. Until then, EMS personnel should be aware that such statements could be used in court as evidence of fault. Senate Bill S4848” As of November 2026, the bill is SLOWLY making its way through NYS government steps and is currently in Senate Committee Rules of the NYS Senate. To date, there has been mass support for its success and hopefully it will be signed into law, however the NYS Legislature will not re-convene until January 6, 2027. If passed by the Legislature, it still must go before the Governor.


We try to show our patients compassion and encouragement. “The New York State Department of Health emphasizes that healthcare is ‘a humans serving humans business’.” What are some of the things we can safely say that will help allay our patient’s fears and hopefully make them more comfortable? The NYS DOH also says “empathy is not an extra — it’s essential to patient safety and satisfaction.” That is a heavy weight to put on EMS providers who are not even allowed to express remorse over the patient’s pain or fears.


To help your patients, it’s valuable to introduce yourself, your name (as a REAL person), and your training (EMT, Paramedic…). Do not make promises but do offer encouragement. Show your patient respect, ask permission (if possible) before touching them, let your patient know that he/she is YOUR focus. Try to explain to your patient what you are doing for them. Importantly, hide your own fear if things seem more serious than you expected.


Rely on what is known as the H.E.L.P. technique: Halt (stop other tasks and focus); Engage (face the patient); Anticipate (be open to what the patient tells you) and finally, Replay (paraphrase what they’ve said to confirm that you understand). Be sure to support their feelings and don’t minimize their concerns, do however be supportive. Do not make promises but let them know why you are doing things that “should help them.” And remember, apologies, use of the words “I’m sorry” can be twisted into confessions.

avatar image
CHELLE CORDEROCorrespondent

I'm a former NYS EMT and still part of an EMS & FD family. I like to think I can write ;)